← Back to Blog

The Fourth Market

November 16, 2026 - Rob Thompson, Realtor

Every agent sorts the housing market into three boxes: a buyer's market, a balanced market, or a seller's market. It is a useful shorthand, and it is wrong in a specific way right now. Those three labels are points on a single number line, and that line measures exactly one thing: who holds the leverage in a deal. It says nothing about whether anyone can actually afford to buy.

For most of history that was fine, because leverage and affordability moved together. A glut of homes came with low prices; a shortage came with high ones. One axis carried both. That is not the market we are in. Supply and affordability have come apart, and when you give affordability its own axis, a fourth market appears that the three old labels have no name for: loose supply that no one can afford to buy into.

Here is Colorado Springs, plotted on both axes, every year from 2012 to now. Drag your eye along the path, hover any year, and then flip to the old one-axis view.

Hover any year. The gold marker is now.
Buyer's marketLoose supply, and payments people can carry. The real one: 2012 to 2015.
Seller's marketTight supply and still affordable, so demand bids it up. 2016 to 2021.
OverheatedTight supply but the payment has run past incomes. The wall forming, 2022.
The unaffordable marketLoose supply, buyer-side leverage, and payments no one can carry. The missing box. Here now.

The path Colorado Springs walked

Start in the bottom right. From 2012 to 2015 the region was a genuine buyer's market: five to six months of supply and a payment that ran about 27 percent of the median income. Cheap and well stocked.

Then it tightened. From 2016 to 2021 supply fell to one or two months and the market became a seller's market, then a boom, but it stayed affordable, because sub-three-percent rates held the payment down even as prices climbed. That is the bottom-left box: tight, but people could still carry it.

In 2022 the payment-to-income ratio jumped from the low thirties into the forties as rates reset, and the market lifted straight up into unaffordable territory. Supply was still tight, so on the old map it still read as a seller's market. It did not feel like one.

Since then inventory has rebuilt. Months of supply has climbed back to the buyer side, which slides the marker to the right. But affordability never came back down. The market did not return to 2012. It walked into a different quadrant entirely.

Why calling today a buyer's market feels wrong

Switch the map above to the old one-axis view. Watch what happens: affordability disappears, and 2014 and today collapse onto the same stretch of the line. Both read as a buyer's market. But they are opposite worlds. One was loose and affordable. The other is loose and unaffordable. The single-axis model cannot tell them apart, which is exactly why today feels off when someone calls it a buyer's market. Buyers have the leverage. They do not have the affordability. Those are two different things, and the old vocabulary only has a word for one of them.

Where we are right now

As of November 2026, Colorado Springs sits at roughly 6.9 months of supply and a payment near 46 percent of the median income. That is the furthest into the fourth quadrant the market has ever been in this record: buyer-side leverage, and an affordability reading that would have been off the chart in the 2010s. It is still drifting to the right as inventory builds. It is not overheated, and it is not a healthy buyer's market. It is the fourth market.

What it means

For a buyer, the leverage is real. Homes sit, sellers negotiate, and there is time to think. Use it. But the leverage does not fix the payment, so make sure the one you sign is affordable for the long term, and do not buy on the assumption that you will refinance your way out of it later.

For a seller, the advantage has moved across the table. Price to the market in front of you, not to 2021. The buyer who can afford your home has options, and the one who loves it may not be able to afford it at all.

And for anyone waiting for this to resolve into a normal buyer's market: the thing that empties the fourth quadrant is not more inventory. We already have the inventory. It is affordability, which means lower rates, higher incomes, or lower prices, working over time. A market can be loose and still be stuck. That is the one the map was missing.

Axes: months of supply (active inventory divided by monthly closings) and payment-to-income (principal, interest, tax and insurance on the median-priced home at that year's rate, over median household income). Annual averages 2012 to 2025; the "now" marker is the trailing 30 days as of November 2026. Source: Odin market data, shouldimovenow.com. Rob Thompson, Realtor.

Share this post

Get the next data drop by email

Original Colorado Springs market numbers you will not find anywhere else. No spam, just the data.

Have questions about the market?

Get personalized guidance from Rob Thompson.

Send Rob a Message

Get Listing Alerts

Get daily email alerts when new homes matching your criteria hit the market.

Save Your Favorites

Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.

No spam, just houses.

By registering, you consent to receive listing alerts from Rob Thompson, Realtor. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Get a Personalized Insurance Quote

Get an accurate homeowner's insurance estimate from Patrick Murakami at Main Street Insurance - no obligation.

Contact a Lender

Get connected with a trusted local lender for pre-approval, rate quotes, or financing questions - no obligation.