Is 80917 a buyer or seller market?
Right now, 80917 (Rustic Hills & Monterey) is a balanced market.
59%
of listings sell (vs expire)
97.2%
sold vs original list
52.8%
got a seller concession
Based on 24 closed and 17 failed listings, trailing 90 days. Full demand and concessions data.

How 80917 holds value

Compare all zips →
3.7%
of homes sold last year (turnover)
-3.7%
1-year appreciation
+9.7%
5-year appreciation
about 1.9%/yr
-5.1
points vs market (5yr)
+95.4%
10-year appreciation
about 6.9%/yr
2006 · $179,900 shaded: 2020 to 2022 surge 2026 · $390,000
Turnover = homes sold in the last 12 months vs the count of homes in 80917 (El Paso County assessor). Appreciation is the change in median sale price. Most of the multi-year gain came in the 2020 to 2022 surge (shaded) and has been roughly flat since, so the per-year rate is the steadier read. "Points vs market" is this zip's five-year appreciation minus the market-wide figure: positive means it beat the market, negative means it lagged. Source: Rob Thompson, Realtor, Iconic Colorado Properties.

Homes for Sale in 80917 - Rustic Hills & Monterey

115 + 25 Active + Under Contract
$356,228 Avg List Price
61 Avg Days on Market
$135,000 Lowest Price
$749,000 Highest Price

Closed Sales - Last 30 Days

24 Sold
$396,147 Avg Close Price
94.5% Avg Close-to-Original List
97.2% Median Close-to-Original List

Market Comparison

$359,975 Area Median Price
24.2% below regional median vs Regional Median ($475,000)

Month-over-Month Trends

↑ +1.9% Avg List Price
↑ +3.1 Avg DOM
+0.2% CPOLP

Showing active residential listings in zip code 80917. Updated every 15 minutes from the elevateMLS.

Get Alerts for 80917

Market Breakdown

Price Distribution

Under $300K
43 (37.4%)
$300K - $450K
51 (44.3%)
$450K - $600K
18 (15.7%)
$600K+
3 (2.6%)

Property Types

Single Family
60 (52.2%)
Townhouse
32 (27.8%)
Condo
23 (20.0%)

Bedrooms

1
1 bd
40
2 bd
32
3 bd
35
4 bd
7
5 bd
140 results · Page 9 of 10
Price Drop - $25,000 off
4916 Horseshoe Bend Street
MLS #: 1410323 More Details →
4916 Horseshoe Bend Street, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $500,000 $475,000
DOM: 84
Taxes: $1,691/yr
Year Built: 1979
Listed By: Coldwell Banker Realty
List Price $475,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,551.13
4578 Adieu Circle
MLS #: 5958482 More Details →
4578 Adieu Circle, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $475,000
DOM: 46
Taxes: $1,317/yr
Year Built: 1971
Listed By: Venterra Real Estate LLC
List Price $475,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,519.90
Under Contract
4045 Haven Lane
MLS #: 8272983 More Details →
4045 Haven Lane, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 5/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $475,000
DOM: 19
Taxes: $1,506/yr
Year Built: 1969
Listed By: Quest Real Estate Partners
List Price $475,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,535.73
Price Drop - $18,000 off
3854 Deepgreen Lane
MLS #: 4976573 More Details →
3854 Deepgreen Lane, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $495,000 $477,000
DOM: 50
Taxes: $1,511/yr
Year Built: 1970
Listed By: LPT Realty LLC
List Price $477,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,549.41
Price Drop - $5,000 off
4932 Horseshoe Bend Street
MLS #: 9094999 More Details →
4932 Horseshoe Bend Street, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $485,000 $480,000
DOM: 15
Taxes: $1,649/yr
Year Built: 1979
Listed By: Coldwell Banker Beyond
List Price $480,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,580.85
4364 Siferd Boulevard
MLS #: 3174421 More Details →
4364 Siferd Boulevard, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 3/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $485,000
DOM: 25
Taxes: $534/yr
Year Built: 2026
Listed By: Live Dream Colorado LLC
List Price $485,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,521.20
4358 Siferd Boulevard
MLS #: 9597260 More Details →
4358 Siferd Boulevard, Colorado Springs
Type: Townhouse
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $494,950
DOM: 266
Taxes: $534/yr
Year Built: 2026
Listed By: Live Dream Colorado LLC
List Price $494,950
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,587.41
5541 Country Heights Drive
MLS #: 8120893 More Details →
5541 Country Heights Drive, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 3/2
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $499,997
DOM: 13
Taxes: $1,484/yr
Year Built: 1982
Listed By: RE/MAX Real Estate Group LLC
List Price $499,997
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,700.15
2565 Brady Drive
MLS #: 6895007 More Details →
2565 Brady Drive, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 5/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $500,000
DOM: 41
Taxes: $1,282/yr
Year Built: 1976
Listed By: HomeSmart
List Price $500,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,683.35
Price Drop - $50,000 off
4350 Valencia Circle
MLS #: 2935084 More Details →
4350 Valencia Circle, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 5/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $550,000 $500,000
DOM: 73
Taxes: $1,747/yr
Year Built: 1973
Listed By: Exp Realty LLC
List Price $500,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,722.14
Under Contract
Price Drop - $25,000 off
2834 Serendipity Circle
MLS #: 6230462 More Details →
2834 Serendipity Circle, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 6/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $525,000 $500,000
DOM: 71
Taxes: $1,355/yr
Year Built: 1969
Listed By: HomeSmart
List Price $500,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,689.44
Price Drop - $10,000 off
3817 Midsummer Lane
MLS #: 6663418 More Details →
3817 Midsummer Lane, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $519,500 $509,500
DOM: 13
Taxes: $1,123/yr
Year Built: 1969
Listed By: Satellite Realty
List Price $509,500
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,733.28
Under Contract
4402 Siferd Boulevard
MLS #: 1951468 More Details →
4402 Siferd Boulevard, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 3/2
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $515,000
DOM: 21
Taxes: $1,000/yr
Year Built: 1957
Listed By: Legends Real Estate
List Price $515,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,759.63
5020 Barcelona Way
MLS #: 5802572 More Details →
5020 Barcelona Way, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/3
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $525,000
DOM: 3
Taxes: $1,552/yr
Year Built: 1975
Listed By: REMAX PROPERTIES
List Price $525,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,872.14
4390 Siferd Boulevard
MLS #: 4940374 More Details →
4390 Siferd Boulevard, Colorado Springs
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80917
Beds/Baths: 4/4
Garage: 2.0
List Price: $549,900
DOM: 116
Taxes: $534/yr
Year Built: 2026
Listed By: Live Dream Colorado LLC
List Price $549,900
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,953.00
Prev 1 ... 7 8 9 10 Next

About 80917 - Rustic Hills & Monterey

Rustic Hills and Monterey — east-central Colorado Springs north of Palmer Park. Established 1970s–1980s neighborhoods with mature landscaping and reasonable prices. Close to the Citadel retail area and Peterson SFB. D11 schools. Reliable mid-price option for buyers who want central access.

Zip code 80917 in Colorado Springs currently has 115 active residential listings ranging from $135,000 to $749,000, with an average list price of $356,228. Homes in this area average 61 days on market. In the last 30 days, 24 homes sold in 80917 at an average close price of $396,147, with buyers paying an average of 94.5% of the original asking price. Estimated monthly payments at 7.0% interest range from approximately $2,685 to $1,196 including taxes and insurance.

Nearby Zip Codes

80909 - East Central & Palmer Park 80915 - East Colorado Springs & Vista Grande 80918 - Briargate & Pine Creek 80914 - Cimarron Hills

School districts serving 80917: Colorado Springs 11

Looking for a home in 80917? Contact Rob Thompson at 719.440.6626 for a personalized home search or visit our monthly payment search to find homes that fit your budget. You can also browse by budget: under $1,500/mo, under $2,000/mo, under $2,500/mo, or under $3,000/mo.

The real estate listing information and related content displayed on this site is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information and related content is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Pikes Peak REALTOR® Services Corp d/b/a elevateMLS. Estimated monthly costs assume 7.0% APR, 30-year fixed, $3,000/yr insurance, and actual taxes. This is not an offer to lend.

Send Rob a Message

Get Listing Alerts

Get daily email alerts when new homes matching your criteria hit the market.

Save Your Favorites

Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.

No spam, just houses.

By registering, you consent to receive listing alerts from Rob Thompson, Realtor. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Get a Personalized Insurance Quote

Get an accurate homeowner's insurance estimate from Patrick Murakami at Main Street Insurance - no obligation.

Contact a Lender

Get connected with a trusted local lender for pre-approval, rate quotes, or financing questions - no obligation.