Listing data may be delayed — showing last known data from 2026-05-17T18:42

Homes for Sale in 80864 — Peyton

8 + 3 Active + Under Contract
$509,487 Avg List Price
59 Avg Days on Market
$216,000 Lowest Price
$789,900 Highest Price

Closed Sales — Last 30 Days

3 Sold
$319,000 Avg Close Price
95.3% Avg Close-to-Original List
97.9% Median Close-to-Original List

Market Comparison

$470,000 Area Median Price
4.1% below regional median vs Regional Median ($490,000)

Month-over-Month Trends

↑ +24.8% Avg List Price
↓ -150.5 Avg DOM
↓ -1.7% CPOLP

Showing active residential listings in zip code 80864. Updated every 15 minutes from the elevateMLS.

Get Alerts for 80864

Market Breakdown

Price Distribution

Under $300K
1 (12.5%)
$300K - $450K
2 (25.0%)
$450K - $600K
2 (25.0%)
$600K+
3 (37.5%)

Bedrooms

1
2 bd
5
4 bd
1
5 bd
1
6+ bd
11 results
Under Contract
Price Drop — $30,000 off
No address provided
MLS #: 4050188 More Details →
No address provided, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $209,000 $179,000
DOM: 133
Taxes: $626/yr
Year Built: 2000
Listed By: Your Home Sold Guaranteed Realty - Barb Has The Buyers Team
List Price $179,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $1,493.06
Price Drop — $51,000 off
31995 Neely
MLS #: 9983385 More Details →
31995 Neely, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $267,000 $216,000
DOM: 75
Taxes: $866/yr
Year Built: 1997
Listed By: Casa Bella Realty
List Price $216,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $1,759.25
35125 Book
MLS #: 4910877 More Details →
35125 Book, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $375,000
DOM: 23
Taxes: $510/yr
Year Built: 1999
Listed By: Keller Williams Partners
List Price $375,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $2,787.36
Under Contract
35875 Shear
MLS #: 9305060 More Details →
35875 Shear, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 3/2
Garage: 6
List Price: $430,000
DOM: 13
Taxes: $134/yr
Year Built: 2001
Listed By: Pikes Peak Dream Homes Realty
List Price $430,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,121.98
35750 Vorenberg
MLS #: 5748691 More Details →
35750 Vorenberg, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $435,000
DOM: 63
Taxes: $15/yr
Year Built: 2026
Listed By: Courlas Realty Inc.
List Price $435,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,145.32
1305 Ramah
MLS #: 5810047 More Details →
1305 Ramah, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $450,000
DOM: 1
Taxes: $925/yr
Year Built: 2018
Listed By: Sailing Stone Real Estate LLC
List Price $450,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,320.96
Under Contract
Price Drop — $20,000 off
810 Awesome
MLS #: 7874062 More Details →
810 Awesome, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/2
Garage: 0
List Price: $500,000 $480,000
DOM: 35
Taxes: $745/yr
Year Built: 2015
Listed By: Exp Realty LLC
List Price $480,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,505.54
37155 Jones
MLS #: 3476722 More Details →
37155 Jones, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 4/4
Garage: 2
List Price: $489,999
DOM: 36
Taxes: $918/yr
Year Built: 1981
Listed By: RE/MAX Real Estate Group LLC
List Price $489,999
Est. Monthly Cost* $3,586.46
33975 Highway 94
MLS #: 9055542 More Details →
33975 Highway 94, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 2/2
Garage: 2
List Price: $650,000
DOM: 2
Taxes: $1,248/yr
Year Built: 2002
Listed By: Real Broker, LLC DBA Real
List Price $650,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $4,678.47
Price Drop — $45,000 off
8450 Edison
MLS #: 8122637 More Details →
8450 Edison, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 6/4
Garage: 2
List Price: $715,000 $670,000
DOM: 197
Taxes: $992/yr
Year Built: 2022
Listed By: Pikes Peak Dream Homes Realty
List Price $670,000
Est. Monthly Cost* $4,790.19
4520 Ramah
MLS #: 2103831 More Details →
4520 Ramah, Yoder
Type: Single Family
Zip: 80864
Beds/Baths: 5/4
Garage: 3
List Price: $789,900
DOM: 72
Taxes: $696/yr
Year Built: 1979
Listed By: Acquire Homes Inc
List Price $789,900
Est. Monthly Cost* $5,563.24

About 80864 — Peyton

Peyton is a small, growing community northeast of Colorado Springs with a rural-suburban mix. Horse properties, small acreages, and newer subdivisions coexist. Peyton D23 schools. Less expensive than Falcon to the west, Peyton appeals to buyers who want land and a quieter lifestyle while staying within reasonable commuting distance.

Zip code 80864 in Colorado Springs currently has 8 active residential listings ranging from $216,000 to $789,900, with an average list price of $509,487. Homes in this area average 59 days on market. In the last 30 days, 3 homes sold in 80864 at an average close price of $319,000, with buyers paying an average of 95.3% of the original asking price. Estimated monthly payments at 7.0% interest range from approximately $3,122 to $4,790 including taxes and insurance.

Nearby Zip Codes

80831 — Falcon & Woodmen Hills 80808 — Calhan & Eastern Plains 80832 — Ellicott

School districts serving 80864: Edison 54 JT, Miami/Yoder 60JT

Looking for a home in 80864? Contact Rob Thompson at 719.440.6626 for a personalized home search or visit our monthly payment search to find homes that fit your budget. You can also browse by budget: under $1,500/mo, under $2,000/mo, under $2,500/mo, or under $3,000/mo.

The real estate listing information and related content displayed on this site is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information and related content is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Pikes Peak REALTOR® Services Corp d/b/a elevateMLS. Estimated monthly costs assume 7.0% APR, 30-year fixed, $3,000/yr insurance, and actual taxes. This is not an offer to lend.

Send Rob a Message

Get Listing Alerts

Get daily email alerts when new homes matching your criteria hit the market.

Save Your Favorites

Create a free account to save listings and get notified when new homes match your criteria.

No spam, just houses.

By registering, you consent to receive listing alerts from Rob Thompson, Realtor. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Get a Personalized Insurance Quote

Get an accurate homeowner's insurance estimate from Patrick Murakami at Main Street Insurance — no obligation.

Contact a Lender

Get connected with a trusted local lender for pre-approval, rate quotes, or financing questions — no obligation.